it's totally within the formula of the notorious FOX contest shows.
charice is doing a good job, but like in germany, the show creates negative sentiments and brute behavior while at the same time gets great ratings. in the US and UK it works better and they are more decent. different humor in the culture.
I'm afraid they will continue to exploit her sensitivity and intense emotion.
their worst prank is juggling with identity and active/passive role.
charice may have true, intense emotion and gets carried away, but the camera/director is creating an image of overreaction, by stressing the other judges soothing her, magnify that picture for a long time, play cheesy super-drama music, all these cheap tools.
so, the overreaction by other persons and the magnifying cam will twist the thing as if it was charice who is overacting and fake.
also, the girl with a low voice, can we be sure it wasn't tampered? currently I have no facility to experiment, but our sound gurus here can give it a try. there is this "voice changer" plugin, they have it in the newer autotune/melodyn suites. to me, it sounds very much like formant resynthesis. definitely, this type of show makes intense use of technology and special effects to create an artificial image of some elements, like incidents, vocal sounds, colors, what-have-you. they love confusion. :) next day, big discussion in the streets. ratings go up then.
they might bring up yogi-flying and faith-healers as well ;)
it's the franchise, it is in the whole contract.
I could recognize many elements of that basic formula.
how to deal with this, I'm not sure.
perhaps audience in return should overreact in such a crass way that producers pee their pants, so to give back the excitement.
or just laugh, and not believe anything that is shown to them.